They are trained to search, analyze, and organize material, and to produce finished articles and even research papers. Ten years ago, the subject of legal protection was understood to be the result of human creative activity; today, the matter is not so clear-cut. Adapting the existing international legal system to new realities seems quite difficult. The key problem is that artificial intelligence has no legal personality: traditional legal systems require the author to be a natural person. This raises the question: who owns the rights to AI-generated content—the algorithm developer, the user who formulated the prompt, or is such content outside the scope of copyright protection? How, then, can copyright be regulated?
This issue can be examined from various perspectives. Traditional authors, for example, oppose granting AI copyright. Creating their works takes a great deal of time and resources. On the other hand, training neural networks requires processing vast quantities of data, much of which is protected by copyright. In its reports, the U.S. Copyright Office has noted that using such materials without a license or a clear consent mechanism may be considered an infringement of rights if it does not fall within the narrow exceptions for “fair use.” However, imposing strict restrictions could make the situation worse and slow technological growth. The industry needs balance. In the long term, this issue may be resolved through hybrid regulatory models that take the interests of all parties into account.
Author: Kristina Davidovna Gvasalia, Candidate of Economic Sciences and Senior Lecturer, Department of World Economy and International Finance, Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation.